Merging those pom files

Having release branches with lots of pom.xml files is not so fun when it comes to merging. A normal merge will detect conflicts in each and everyone of the pom files. (If you insist on having the version number in each pom file. This can be avoided by parameterizing the version number in the parent pom.) Luckily git can help a bit to solve this. The default merge strategy (called recursive) will mark any conflicts and leave it up to you to resolve them. However if you pass in the -X flag you can configure the way a recursive merge works. One option is to decide to use ours or theirs changes when detecting conflicts. In the pom file example you would likely want to keep ours when merging to master. Call it with:

git merge -X ours release-branch

or if you want to be specific

git merge -s recursive -X ours release-branch

or even more specific

git merge --strategy=recursive --strategy-option=ours release-branch

The problem with this is that if you have conflicts in the actual code you will have to deal with it separately. In this case it is probably wise to set up a merge branch to do the merging on. First merge the code stuff and then move on with pom files.

Other cool things I learned when playing with this:

  • while recursive is default when merging a single head octopus is the default strategy when merging several heads. I have a hard time coming up with a scenario where I would actually want to merge several heads into one merge commit. But it is a cool feature.
  • another strategy option for the recursive strategy is patience - this will give even better merge results in some cases and should probably be used when there has been many changes between the merge subjects. Patience is also an option to the diff command.

Another option is of course to not use maven at all…. :-)

comments powered by Disqus